June 27th, 2023

Discover Millville

Hi, we’re Millville Insurance, the trusted choice of thousands since 1875. If you haven't crossed paths with us before, please take a few moments to get to know us. 

Headquartered in Millville, Pennsylvania, we proudly extend our insurance coverage to properties in both Pennsylvania and New York. What sets us apart is our foundation as a mutual company and that we are owned by our policyholders. We prioritize them above all else, ensuring that their interests come first in everything we do.

Millville Mission

Here at Millville Insurance, trust is not just a word to us; it is the cornerstone of our existence. With a rich heritage spanning over a century, Millville Insurance has earned an unwavering reputation for trust and reliability. In 2022, we were recognized by A.M Best for “Standing the Test of Time”, by maintaining a strong rating of A or higher for 50 consecutive years. The ability to pay claims when they occur is a key component of that A rating; it’s something we take great pride in and that you can confidently rely on.


Stand Out

Prepare to experience insurance PROTECTION YOUR WAY. Our approach allows you to enjoy the benefit of lower insurance premiums and empowers you to choose coverage based on your needs. Our flexibility extends to homes, rentals, small businesses, farms, and more.

Understanding that everyone has unique needs and risk tolerances, we match you with coverage that aligns to you. We don’t push for more coverage than you desire or require. Moreover, we collaborate with esteemed partners to offer supplementary protection options, such as home cyber, underground utility lines and equipment breakdown. Our comprehensive approach ensures an insurance package that fits your budget.

Trusted Agents

At Millville Insurance, our agents are the backbone of our success. We’ve developed strong, lasting relationships with our valued agents who wholeheartedly embrace the efficient and unwavering support we provide. These everyday people, just like you, have worked hard for their homes, farms, and businesses. Their commitment and dedication are why we place so much trust in them. Their loyalty speaks volumes, with some agents having been by our side for over four decades. We truly understand the significance of these partnerships and work tirelessly to ensure their experience collaborating with us is seamless and fulfilling. Together, we stand united, fully dedicated to delivering outstanding service and affordable coverage to our policyholders, guaranteeing their peace of mind.

Partner Quotes
Unmatched Service


At Millville Insurance, we are dedicated to providing exceptional customer service that revolves around your needs and convenience. We believe in going above and beyond to earn your satisfaction and trust.

We strive to be accessible and available to speak with you. We understand the importance of prompt and reliable communication, and we are committed to being there for you whenever you need us.


To further enhance your experience, we offer a user-friendly self-service portal and mobile app. MyMillville puts you in control, allowing you to view your policies, view or pay your bill, submit claims, and access important documents. It's like having your own personalized insurance hub at your fingertips! We take pride in our streamlined and efficient systems that have been purposefully built to make your insurance journey seamless. Our processes are designed to provide swift turnaround times, ensuring that you receive the coverage you need without unnecessary delays.



Thank you for taking the time to get to know Millville Insurance better. We hope this glimpse into who we are and what we offer has piqued your interest. Our commitment to protecting our policyholders is unwavering, and we are dedicated to continuing our legacy of service. As we embrace the digital age, we are excited to announce that Millville Insurance can now be found on Facebook and LinkedIn! We invite you to connect with us on these platforms, enabling us to easily communicate and stay connected with you.

If our approach to exceptional insurance protection resonates with you, we would be thrilled to hear from you. Visit our website at www.millvilleinsurance.com to dive deeper into our comprehensive offerings and locate the agency nearest to you. Should you have any questions or require further assistance, our contact information is readily available on our website. We are eagerly awaiting the opportunity to work with you and provide PROTECTION YOUR WAY with the reliable insurance solutions YOU deserve!


Find an Agent

Millville Mutual’s independent agents hold our same customer-first values.
They’re experts on functional replacement costs and are ready to stand by your side as a partner to protect your properties, your way.

Find an Agent