Locate an Agent:

Best's Review for Insurers

Standing the Test of Time


We are proud to be recognized by
A.M. Best for our long history of financial stability.

©A.M.Best – used with permission

Policyholder Comments

  • MONTOURSVILLE, PA Everyone that I had contact with at Millville Insurance Co was great and very helpful to take care of my claim! I am very happy that I have kept my farm and home Insurance with Millville Insurance for almost 50 years! Thank You ~February, 2025
  • SHAMOKIN DAM, PA We are very happy with our experience with Millville Mutual. The adjuster responded quickly with answers to all of our questions multiple times though the process. 5 stars! ~August, 2025
  • PROSPECT, PA Very quick and responsive. Couldn't be happier with the service. ~March, 2025
  • LAKEWOOD, NY Quick response times, fast turn around, and simple online process. Whole process what much easier than I was originally expecting. ~September, 2025

Find an Agent

Millville Mutual is licensed to issue policies within the Commonwealth of PA.