Locate an Agent:

Best's Review for Insurers

Standing the Test of Time


We are proud to be recognized by
A.M. Best for our long history of financial stability.

©A.M.Best – used with permission

Policyholder Comments

  • JAMESTOWN, NY I was very pleased with everything that has transpired with Millville. My ajuster was exceptionally pleasant and nice to work with. I would gladly recommend Millville Insurance to anyone. ~April, 2026
  • MONTOURSVILLE, PA Very friendly and prompt responses ~October, 2025
  • LYNDORA, PA My adjuster was great. Very helpful and did a great job explaining things. ~November, 2025
  • SALAMANCA, NY My adjuster was very professional, informative, and kind. I am very satisfied with the way that my claim was handled. I will recommend this company to others. ~November, 2025

Find an Agent

Millville Mutual is licensed to issue policies within the Commonwealth of PA.