As a Millville Mutual agent, you’ll have the power to rewrite people’s futures – the way they imagine them. In turn, the community you work in will be forever changed.


Let's Become Partners

  • Serve Our Customers, Not UsAs a Millville Mutual independent agent, you can focus solely on customers’ needs. We serve budget conscious homeowners, landlords covering their investments, starter home buyers, commercial property owners, small business owners, farm owners, and so many more.
  • Sensible Insurance SolutionsWe believe that customers know the weight their properties hold on their futures. In the event of damage to their property, each homeowner, farmer, and business owner has their own unique plans. Our insurance coverage allows them to prepare for the futures they envision.
  • Commit to InnovationThe world is constantly evolving. That means the policies you offer customers should, too. With dedicated agents, like you, by our side, we’re committed to innovating our exclusive product offerings. The one factor that remains throughout 140+ years of service is our policyholder-first mindset.



"Resolution was fast and efficient."
- Customer

Nearly 150 Years in Business

AM Best Logo

Rated "A" by AM Best Company

"Very fast and proficient."
- Customer



What Agents are Saying

  • AgentVery easy process from quoting to application and endorsements.
  • AgentClaims are handled quickly, and I always get good comments from insureds about their claims handling.
  • AgentThrough my experience they are the best property company I represent and the easiest to work with.
  • AgentMy agency has been with Millville Insurance Company for many years. We have always had great success with them.
Get Started

Our team is ready to answer your questions about becoming a Millville Mutual independent agent. All that you have to do is start a no-pressure conversation.

Contact Us