Locate an Agent:

Best's Review for Insurers

Standing the Test of Time


We are proud to be recognized by
A.M. Best for our long history of financial stability.

©A.M.Best – used with permission

Policyholder Comments

  • SHAMOKIN DAM, PA We are very happy with our experience with Millville Mutual. The adjuster responded quickly with answers to all of our questions multiple times though the process. 5 stars! ~August, 2025
  • PULASKI, NY Our adjuster has been the best to work with! Very prompt and answered all our questions. ~March, 2026
  • JAMESTOWN, PA We were impressed with the quick response of the claims adjuster.Hearing his suggestion for a solution and the promptness of the check, we were able to solve our problem quickly. We are highly satisfied with our dealing with Millville Insurance. ~September, 2025
  • MARYSVILLE, PA My adjuster was a pleasure to work with through this whole process. It was my first time ever having to file a homeowners claim, so I had many questions just to be sure I was doing everything right on my end. He answered any questions I had, and made the process very smooth.If I had to rate my experience working with both my adjuster and Millville, I would rate it an 11 out of 10! Thank you so much. ~May, 2026

Find an Agent

Millville Mutual is licensed to issue policies within the Commonwealth of PA.